
Although I'm of course delighted about this and was tickled to here the strength and clarity of the singing, there is actually very little room for boasting. First of all, it isn't high poetry. One day I say down and said, "I think it would be good for a congregation to have a hymn that combines the invocation of the Holy Spirit, the biblical symbols of the Holy Spirit, and the sacramental actions of the Church." So I wrote it, in a meter that I now realize was too short. (Longer metrical lines have more space to write in, so they are better for theologically heavier subjects.) 'Twas a beast. The rhymes are forced, the diction stunted. There's a line in verse 3 that says "Grace them with sanctifying speech." Ironically, that line is extremely ungraceful in sound, and it is not natural. Flaws like that, and failures in meter and rhythm, run throughout the text.
And then, an old good teacher of mine is on the faculty, and while he congratulated me very heartily, he also (as is his honest style) pointed out a number of serious flaws in the text. He's almost totally right. So again, that's a very helpful strike against boasting!
On the other hand, Jesus very pointedly said in the Gospel, several times, that God will not fail to give the Holy Spirit to anyone who asks. And today there did seem to be a real request made. There was a certain readiness on the part of the congregation to sing the hymn, and again, an unusual vigor. And there seemed to be a tone set, there, at the very beginning of the year, that involves the light of the Holy Spirit fulfilling God's will, as we each work on our own limited part of the whole mission of the Church.
Come, Holy Spirit. Fill the hearts of Your faithful, and enkindle in them the fire of your love!
2 comments:
Curious, are the "flaws" in the text pointed out by your teacher theological or poetic?
Care to share?
Dear Anonymous,
Good question!! My guess is that you are interested in knowing whether my hymn told the truth, theologically. You and I are of one mind about this, if I understand you correctly.
Before I published the booklet that contains this hymn, I sent it to a number of friends. Almost all of them were in advanced degree programs, mostly in theology. I have a Masters' degree in theology and was taking further courses in Thomistic theology at the time I wrote these hymns. I received many excellent criticisms and took them all into consideration.
My professor is an expert on the role of the Holy Spirit in the life of the Church--the subject of the hymn. His criticisms were entirely poetic.
Post a Comment